Support the Free Press. Facts matter. Truth matters. Journalism matters. Salt Lake City Weekly has been Utah's source of independent news and in-depth journalism since 1984. Donate today to ensure the legacy continues.
This just in: Most of the people at Sundance—and most of the
people in the entertainment industry—are liberals. In other breaking news,
there’s a lot of snow here. ---
This demographic phenomenon is what it is, but it presents a
programming challenge for the festival, particularly where the documentaries are
concerned. Year in and year out, they deal with issues from a largely
left-of-center perspective. And the 2010 Documentary Competition slate is no
different, as you glance through summaries of movies about rapacious natural
gas leasing, the failing education system, political corruption, the war in Afghanistan
and abortion.
But filmmakers can demonstrate widely different levels of
appreciation for looking at a subject from more than one point of view. On the
down side is Alex Gibney’s Casino Jack
and the United States of Money. I have little doubt that Gibney (Taxi to the Dark Side) could have filled
four hours of screen time with all the shenanigans of Jack Abramoff, the Washington lobbyist,
wheeler-dealer and world-class jagoff whose ultimate downfall also brought down
several congressmen. That doesn’t mean that a mere two hours’ worth can’t still
become dizzying and overwhelming. Gibney catalogs a host of Abramoff’s most
notorious capers—his double-dealing with American Indian tribes over
representing their casino interests; creating shadow “non-profit” organizations
as money-laundering fronts for political payoffs; figuring out ways around
various laws to allow sweatshop labor in the commonweath of Saipan—with
understandable outrage, ultimately making him the poster child for the
overwhelming power of cash to manipulate the American political process. But
Gibney doesn’t really build a narrative so much as throw out the evidence, and
his heavy-elbow-nudging song cues only underline a vague sense of
self-congratulation for giving these misdeeds a cinematic airing. As a populist
call to arms, it starts to feel like two hours of someone blowing the bugle in
your ear.
By comparison, check out 12th
& Delaware.
Across the street from one another at an intersection in Fort
Pierce, Florida are two rival
businesses of a unique nature: A Woman’s World is a clinic that performs
abortions, and the competition is a CatholicChurch-runCrisisPregnancyCenter.
Heidi Ewing and Rachel Grady (Jesus Camp)
use this dichotomy as a distillation of the American abortion debate, but it’s
more than simply a convenient gimmick. Taking advantage of access to both
sides—and being remarkably even-handed in the portrayal even of the
day-in/day-out protesters—the filmmakers dig deeply into the intense emotions
on both sides. And even taking into account the likely sympathies of a Sundance
audience, it would be amazing if audiences couldn’t connect with the passionate
feelings of Anne Lotierzo, the CrisisPregnancyCenter’s
director. Their “by any means necessary” tactics are bound to infuriate some,
but it’s possible to wonder what else you should expect of those who feel
nothing less than the soul of humanity—not just individual infant souls—is at
stake. If art isn’t challenging you to explore what you think, rather than just
congratulating you for what you already think, what is it good for?