Bread and Circus | Buzz Blog
Support the Free Press.
Facts matter. Truth matters. Journalism matters.
Salt Lake City Weekly has been Utah's source of independent news and in-depth journalism since 1984.
Donate today to ensure the legacy continues.

Bread and Circus

Gymnastics, Medicaid and taxes, oh my! Week 1 of the legislative session is all wrapped up.


  • Kelan Lyons

On Friday afternoon, Logan Dooley and the Flying Ace All Stars transformed the stately and historic Capitol Rotunda into Utah’s most beautiful gymnasium. Dooley and several peers, all professional athletes, twirled and backflipped beneath the colorful paintings of pioneers. Their falls were broken not by the hard marble floor, but by two giant trampolines that launched them high above the steps leading to the ceremonial Supreme Court chamber.

A bird's-eye view of Friday's Tourism Day on the Hill. - KELAN LYONS
  • Kelan Lyons
  • A bird's-eye view of Friday's Tourism Day on the Hill.

Dooley hoped all the bouncing and flipping would inspire those in the Rotunda—munching on sandwiches, wraps and ice cream for Tourism Day on the Hill—to leave the Capitol feeling inspired to embark on an adventure of their own. “We are here to entertain and have fun,” Dooley said before his set.

The fanfare was a celebration of Utah’s tourism industry, which Vicki Varela said generated $1.3 billion in state and local tax revenues last year. That’s $1,375 less that each Utah household had to pay in taxes in 2017. “I always say we should hug the tourists when we see them on the street because they’re saving us from paying higher taxes,” Varela, the state’s director of tourism, said. “Tourism is one of the very few parts of state government where we can measure very precisely that we’re generating revenue for the state.”

Dooley and the All Stars’ aerial wizardry was an apt conclusion to Week 1 of the legislative session, a political carnival that’ll stretch on for the next eight weeks. In his State of the State speech on Wednesday night, Gov. Gary Herbert echoed House Speaker Rep. Brad Wilson, R-Kaysville, by calling for a record-breaking $225 million tax cut. A few breaths later, Herbert said lawmakers will need to alter the voter-approved Medicaid expansion that’s expected to provide health coverage to 150,000 Utahns come April.

On Monday, the session’s first day, protestors rallied at the Capitol to support Proposition 3, the Medicaid expansion ballot initiative that voters passed in November. Citing concerns over cost, Republicans are mulling over advancing Senate Bill 196, which would cap enrollment in the program and institute a work requirement for beneficiaries. The Senate voted in favor of the bill on Wednesday. They’ll vote again in the coming days, once its fiscal note is finalized. If it passes the Senate, SB 196 will be sent to the House for approval. According to The Salt Lake Tribune, Herbert is likely to sign the bill into law if it reaches his desk.

Tourism Day’s cacophony carried throughout the Capitol’s four floors, to where Andrew Riggle, a public policy analyst for the Salt Lake City nonprofit Disability Law Center, sat in his wheelchair and prepared for the afternoon’s committee hearings. Riggle has been at the Capitol for all five of the session’s days so far, keeping tabs on bills and policies that would expand services to people with disabilities. But preserving Prop 3’s Medicaid expansion is his number one priority.

“It is the thing that will make the difference for 150,000 Utahns,” Riggle said. “And many of those individuals will have disabilities, especially mental health needs, and there are some individuals who are eligible now but who have a significant out-of-pocket cost attached to it because they have to spend down in order to be eligible.”

Riggle has been observing Utah’s legislative sessions for the past 14 years. “I don’t remember anything like this,” he said. It looks to him like the Legislature is actively and directly opposing Utahns’ collective will, choosing instead to overwrite a ballot initiative that passed with 53 percent of voters’ support. “Even for Utah,” Riggle said, “this is unique.”

As the aerialists flipped and spun below, Riggle remained concerned about what was happening a few floors above, where lawmakers were wrestling with how to change the state’s expansion of Medicaid. “The guys on the trampoline are a nice visual,” he said. “You have something to point to and say, ‘This is what our money is going to. This is what it’s going to support.’ Poor people, because they don’t have the time, because they’re working a job, they’re taking care of their kids, or they’re too sick, can’t be up here.”

Those are the people, Riggle said, he keeps in mind when he goes to the Capitol each morning. “If folks aren’t able to be here, they don’t have a voice,” he mused. “Legislators don’t hear it like they’re hearing the echoing in the Rotunda now. And, if they aren’t able to see it, if they aren’t able to hear it, they can pretend it doesn’t exist.”