More Light Than Heat | Film & TV | Salt Lake City | Salt Lake City Weekly
We need your help.

Newspapers and media companies nationwide are closing or suffering mass layoffs since the coronavirus impacted all of us starting in March. City Weekly's entire existence is directly tied to people getting together in groups--in clubs, restaurants, and at concerts and events--which are the industries most affected by new coronavirus regulations.

Our industry is not healthy. Yet, City Weekly has continued publishing thanks to the generosity of readers like you. Utah needs independent journalism more than ever, and we're asking for your continued support of our editorial voice. We are fighting for you and all the people and businesses hardest hit by this pandemic.

You can help by making a one-time or recurring donation on, which directs you to our Galena Fund 501(c)(3) non-profit, a resource dedicated to help fund local journalism. It is never too late. It is never too little. Thank you.

News » Film & TV

More Light Than Heat

The solid parts of Ask the Dust never connect as a whole.



When I first met him,” says costume designer Albert Wolsky about Ask the Dust star Colin Farrell, “he had long hair and was wearing those grungy jeans. After they took him into hair and makeup, and he put on the suit I’d made, he was transformed into a young man living in the ’30s.” There are many individual pleasures to be found in writer/director Robert Towne’s film, and one of the most satisfying comes in watching Farrell take yet another character who couldn’t be more removed from the actor himself and make that character so solid, real and grounded that watching him isn’t like watching an actor at work'it’s like making a new acquaintance.

Not quite like making a new friend'at least not in the case of Arturo Bandini, the hungry, naïve young Italian-American writer Farrell plays in Dust. For Arturo isn’t a real warm guy, nor is he terribly likeable. He’s vain and petty and angry and bitter'one of those young men who’s so much younger than he is but believes he’s so very wise.

He’s not a particularly pleasant person, but he is fascinating. And that’s not because of hair or makeup or costuming'no disrespect to the fine production team here'but because Farrell layers Arturo’s immaturity with an anxious vulnerability, a terrible fear that the nagging suspicions Arturo has about his own inadequacies might actually be true. Farrell pulls off here what is unfortunately all-too-rare in film acting: He understands the character he’s playing better than the character understands himself, and uses that knowledge to spin a bit of movie magic.

That’s a good thing, because Dust is based on the novel of the same name by John Fante. Both novel and movie are very much a character study of Arturo, who was, apparently, very much a stand-in for Fante. The misery of being a creative person desperate to make a mark on the world with one’s art, combined with the barely tamped-down panic that one has nothing genuine to offer, is all over the film. In that respect, at least Towne has given Fante a worthy little memorial in the film.

But another, essential element of movie magic is missing. Movies can get away with not having among their casts actors as intense and dedicated as Farrell, but they succeed when they generate that ineffable alchemy in which all the elements work together to become greater than the mere sum of their parts, when everything catches fire and blazes to life. That Ask the Dust never catches fire is a mystery, and a tragedy. You sense that it’s on the verge of greatness, and it’s a frustrating exercise trying to figure out why it ultimately fails.

There’s palpable chemistry, for instance, between Farrell and Salma Hayek as Camilla, the Mexican waitress he can’t help but fall for. Hayek is a firecracker, and Camilla is hot, sweet and sexually dangerous to the inexperienced Arturo'thinking of the, um, storied Farrell convincingly portraying a shy, blustering virgin gives me delicious shivers of appreciation for his talent. The world in which they live'Los Angeles in the depths of the Great Depression'is rife with bigotry and suspicion of their “kinds,” the “wop” and the “spic,” and it drives their aversion to each other. They both have dreams of marrying “real” “Americans” (i.e., rich blonds) as a way of elevating their sorry stations, which overlays their powerful attraction. It comes out in a kind of neo-noir snappishness, a witty, sexy aggression that shows off how formidable Farrell and Hayek are as performers.

There’s Donald Sutherland, turning in perhaps his second best performance ever (after last year’s Pride and Prejudice) as Arturo’s withered neighbor in a shabby Bunker Hill boarding house. There’s Idina Menzel as the lonely woman who idealizes the romanticism of Arturo’s work and pursues his affections'that whole sequence, kudos to Towne, has an air of fantasy about it, as if it were Arturo’s fevered writerly imaginings about women and sex. There’s the stunning re-creation of Bunker Hill'built, apparently, on a high-school soccer field in Cape Town'and the gorgeous muted palette of Caleb Deschanel’s cinematography that evokes sun and dust and heat.

But, alas, all the heat is there in the glare of the Los Angeles sun. There’s no one to blame for how Ask the Dust never becomes greater than the sum of its many great parts. It simply never generates the gravity to ignite.