Now, it’s easy for me to think “You guys worked hard to get in there, you get what you deserve.” But I’m not sure that’s how I should be thinking. The ACLU and advocacy groups feel differently than that, of course. Inhumane is inhumane, and our job as the humane part of society is to humanely rehabilitate if possible, and secure in all cases, those who break the law seriously enough to land in prison. To dehumanize them would make us hardly better than those who broke the law. And in that case, we are simply living in a society in which the rule of law no longer applies.—Utah Politico Hub
Detractors, including many health and human-rights advocates, argue that stings are only as good as their ability to actually improve lives—and that they often do the opposite. “The appeal of the rescue is that it’s a happy ending,” says Janie Chuang, who teaches courses on trafficking at American University’s Washington College of Law. “But it’s not. It’s a really hard life.”
In some cases, victims are quickly cut loose because governments lack the resources or concern to assist them. Others choose to leave protective services; sometimes they fear that authorities will abuse them or that traffickers will do the same to their families. (This is to say nothing of rescued adults who weren’t trafficked at all but had chosen to be sex workers, a distinction that raid groups often fail to make.) Mother Jones found in 2003 that girls and women saved in an IJM bust in Thailand were “locked into two rooms of an orphanage by Public Welfare authorities” and were allowed outside for only one hour each day. Following up on the operation featured on Dateline, the Nation reported in 2009 that some of the rescued children were addicted to intravenous drugs and made deals with the police to keep using; at least a dozen ran away and returned to brothels. “You hear about the raid, but you don’t hear a lot about the safe houses, the rehab process,” says Gretchen Soderlund, a professor at the University of Oregon who studies trafficking.—Foreign Policy