Zinke Does Bears Ears | Buzz Blog
Support the Free Press | Facts matter. Truth matters. Journalism matters
Salt Lake City Weekly has been Utah's source of independent news and in-depth journalism since 1984. Donate today to ensure the legacy continues.

Zinke Does Bears Ears

Interior Secretary visits national monument, but is he listening?


House on Fire Ruin in upper Mule Canyon, near Comb Ridge. - JOHN FOWLER VIA WIKIMEDIA COMMONS
  • John Fowler via Wikimedia Commons
  • House on Fire Ruin in upper Mule Canyon, near Comb Ridge.

On soil of a newly minted national monument, Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke was introduced on Monday by Gov. Gary Herbert as a man with “an open mind and an unbiased attitude.”

An important position for someone who is expected to wade through the controversy of Bears Ears National Monument and decide its fate in the coming weeks. Last month, President Donald Trump signed an executive order instructing Zinke to begin a 45-day review of all the national monuments created in the last two decades.

Supporters of the executive order, including Utah’s congressional delegation, are hopeful that it will undo or shrink Bears Ears, an act that might not be lawful and, if attempted, is expected to be challenged in court.

While Zinke reiterates that he hasn’t made a decision, he’s already drawing criticism from environmental groups who say he appears to be listening more to the side that wants to rescind Bears Ears.

The Sierra Club published a piece whose author, Stacy Bare, said she was optimistic Zinke would proceed judiciously, but noted concern that he had overwhelmingly placed himself within ear reach of those opposed to Bears Ears.

“While in Utah, Zinke only met with a carefully curated batch of interest groups,” she wrote. “Pro-monument supporters were sidelined or chastised when they confronted Zinke. Worse, important pro-monument stakeholders—even the chamber of commerce for the two rural communities most heavily impacted by the monuments, Boulder-Escalante—were denied meetings, along with military veterans and pro-monument Native American community organizations.”

Zinke met with Tribal Council for about an hour. But most alarming to Utah Diné Bikéyah, the group that first began petitioning for a national monument, the Interior Secretary didn’t visit the mostly Native American communities in southern San Juan County.

“Perhaps the reason why he didn’t meet with those people is because Utah’s elected officials and governor don’t actually know what’s happening down there and don’t know who the people are that wrote the Bears Ears proposal,” Utah Diné Bikéyah Executive Director Gavin Noyes said.

Zinke flew down to southern Utah with Herbert, for example, who has been railing against Bears Ears’ monument designation since its inception. For the most part, Utah’s elected officials say they agree that the area should be protected, but they believe a national monument is not the appropriate course.

Bears Ears was the only monument mentioned by Trump at his executive order ceremony, but it’s among a list of 22 national monuments found in 11 states. Additionally, Zinke has been asked to review four marine national monuments.

Proponents worry that the level of understanding needed to make an important land-use decision can’t be gained in a brief stop.

“A tip of the hat—in the form of a one-hour meeting with Tribal leaders—is a start, but insufficient to provide Secretary Zinke with the depth of information he needs to make his appropriate decision,” Willie Greyeyes, Utah Diné Bikéyah board chair, said in a statement. “Sixty percent of San Juan County residents live south of Blanding, yet he only set foot in the wealthy, non-Native, anti-monument portion of the county. It is a whole different world down here.”