Zinke's Bears Ears Recommend Released | Buzz Blog
Support the Free Press | Facts matter. Truth matters. Journalism matters
Salt Lake City Weekly has been Utah's source of independent news and in-depth journalism since 1984. Donate today to ensure the legacy continues.

Zinke's Bears Ears Recommend Released

Interior Secretary weighs in on Nat'l Monument.


Moon Shot in Cedar Mesa in Bears Ears National Monument. - US BUREAU OF LAND MANAGEMENT
  • US Bureau of Land Management
  • Moon Shot in Cedar Mesa in Bears Ears National Monument.

After a 45-day review, Interior Secretary Ryan Zinke said on a conference call Monday his office is recommending that President Donald Trump re-draw Bears Ears National Monument’s boundary—though it’s still up in the air how much land he wants to shave from the 1.3-million-acre monument.

Zinke is basing his recommendation off a listening tour, he said, that brought him to Southern Utah last month. The conversations he had, in part, led him to believe that reducing instead of eliminating the national monument is the right choice, adding that he has “no doubt” dwellings, archeology sites and petroglyphs deserved protection through the Antiquities Act.

“These items can be identified, segregated and reasonably separated,” he said.

Protection for the rest of the land, however, is TBD.

Zinke held his conference call the same day his office released an interim report addressed to the president. In his memo, Zinke wrote that sizable sections of Bears Ears are suitable for “recreation; grazing; timber harvest; mining; and traditional activities such as gathering of medicinal herbs and plants; hunting, fishing, and wood gathering.”

Locals flooded the Utah State Capitol on May 6 in support of Bears Ears. - SARAH ARNOFF
  • Sarah Arnoff
  • Locals flooded the Utah State Capitol on May 6 in support of Bears Ears.
In addition to shrinking the monument, Zinke suggests that the president ask Congress to establish a co-management agreement with vested tribes, draft additional conservation legislation as needed, and clarify the designated wilderness and wilderness study areas within Bears Ears.

Many of Utah’s elected officials have been beating the anti-monument drum since Day 1, so it’s no surprise then that the state delegation, as well as Gov. Gary Herbert, met this news with glee.

Sen. Orrin Hatch released a video applauding Zinke’s recommendation to shrink the monument:

“I’m even more grateful for the thoughtful and inclusive process that led us to this point. Secretary Zinke heard from everyone: community leaders, conservationists, tribal leaders, from those clearly opposed to any monument to those who attempted to shout him down when he visited our state,” he said, lightly chuckling as he mentioned the protesters.

When Zinke visited Utah to meet with stakeholders and tour the land, he was criticized by some who accused him of spending most of his time listening to the faction who opposed Bears Ears. And though Zinke maintains he approached his task in a balanced and unbiased fashion, when Trump ordered the interior secretary to review a long list of national monuments, he stood with opponents of the monument and used phrases—“give the land back to the people,” for example—that implied the president knew which direction he expected the review to take.

In a statement, Rep. Chris Stewart, R-Utah, called the move a “win-win.” Herbert described it as an “important first step toward re-establishing sound land management practices,” and Rep. Jason Chaffetz said this was the beginning of “reversing President Obama’s gross abuse of the Antiquities Act.”

Zinke said a final recommendation will be made after all the other monuments have been reviewed. Public comments will be accepted through July 10. As the original comment deadline approached, supporters urged the public to tell Zinke that they stood with Bears Ears, including Salt Lake City Mayor Jackie Biskupski.

“Our Capital City is the gateway to the majestic national parks and monuments that make Southern Utah a worldwide tourist destination,” she wrote. “These lands are powerful economic drivers for our city, with thousands of visitors launching their adventures to these iconic landscapes from Salt Lake City.”

For those who support Bears Ears National Monument, the comment period extension gives them about a month to try to sway the feds from reversing the designation.

Utah Diné Bikéyah, a grassroots organization that initially pushed for a national monument, said in a statement Monday’s announcement was about “appeasing political allies and special interests.”

“If the Administration proceeds in attempting to shrink the monument, we could lose funding potential, proactive management, and law enforcement resources for the land that would no longer be included in the monument,” the statement read.

Utah Diné Bikéyah indicated it would fight the decision in court if Trump goes through with Zinke’s recommendations.

The Wilderness Society reacted to the news saying it amounted to “nothing less than an attack on the future of all American monuments, parks and public lands.”